Eric Virey | Yole Development: Why hasn't OLED closed the cost gap with LCD, and how do quantum dots keep LCD competitive?
03:58 - 05:45
Other snippets from this talk
Summary of the clip:
Why hasn't OLED closed the cost gap with LCD, and how do quantum dots keep LCD competitive?
When the first OLED TV came to market around 2013, there was great hope that cost would come down significantly. OLED is self-emissive with pixel-level dimming and clearly better picture quality, so one would expect it to have taken over by now. Its structure is essentially intrinsically simpler than LCD, yet it remains quite expensive to manufacture. So far OLED has failed to deliver on the cost promise and has failed to close the cost gap with LCD.
Meanwhile LCD performance has increased and improved continuously. It was thought that LCD was a fairly mature technology with little room for improvement, but the industry has been very creative, coming up with many ways to supercharge LCD by adding other technologies that help improve performance. The first and most widespread route today is narrowband downconverters: quantum dots, narrowband phosphors, perovskites, whatever form they take.
Those narrowband downconverters deliver a significant performance improvement already, in terms of color, brightness and power consumption. Crucially, those benefits now come at a fairly low implementation cost. The material cost is quite reasonable, and TV makers do not need any capital expenditure to implement the improvements. The picture-quality push from OLED is therefore answered without a new investment cycle on the LCD side.
In this short video, you can learn:
* A structurally simpler, self-emissive OLED stack has still not translated into low manufacturing cost, so the gap to LCD remains open more than a decade after the first sets.
* LCD was assumed to be mature with little room left, yet creativity let the industry supercharge it with narrowband downconverters such as quantum dots, narrowband phosphors and perovskites.
* Those downconverters buy significant gains in color, brightness and power consumption at reasonable material cost and with no capital expenditure required from TV makers.
đź“‹ **Clip Abstract** OLED arrived in 2013 with a simpler, self-emissive structure and pixel-level dimming, yet it stayed expensive and never closed the cost gap with LCD. Narrowband downconverters such as quantum dots, narrowband phosphors and perovskites now lift LCD color, brightness and power consumption at low material cost and zero capital expenditure.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Eric Virey
* Company: Yole Development
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#NarrowbandDownconverter, #QuantumDotColorConversion, #NarrowbandPhosphor, #SelfEmissivePixels, #DisplayMaterials, #TVPanelEconomics
This is a highlight of the presentation:
Quantum Dots, OLED, MiniLED, MicroLED NanoLED: technology landscape for next generations TVs
More Highlights from the same talk.
06:32 - 08:32
How many zones and LEDs should a MiniLED backlight use before cost outweighs contrast gains?
How many zones and LEDs should a MiniLED backlight use before cost outweighs contrast gains?
MiniLED backlights extend existing full-array local dimming by increasing both the number of LEDs and the number of independent zones in the backlight. This finer brightness modulation lets the backlight fit image requirements, enabling very deep black and higher contrast. The trade-off is higher complexity and cost. The design question is a balance between zone and LED count, not a simple push toward more of both.
Early prototypes shown at trade shows varied widely: from a couple thousand zones up to close to 10,000 zones, and from a few thousand LEDs to almost 200,000 LEDs. TCL’s V-Drean at CES 2020 had 5,000 zones and 20,000 LEDs; it was supposed to be commercialized through 2020, but that did not happen. Commercial products now reaching shelves are more reasonable in zone count.
The analysis expects some midterm convergence because increasing zone count has diminishing returns. Picture quality does not improve much more above, say, a few thousand zones. That statement is the key constraint: beyond that range, adding zones and LEDs raises complexity and cost without proportional contrast gains. The question therefore becomes where the practical zone and LED count settles for commercial MiniLED backlights.
In this short video, you can learn:
* MiniLED backlights increase LED count and independent zones to modulate brightness for deeper black and higher contrast, at the expense of complexity and cost.
* Prototype designs ranged from about 2,000 to nearly 10,000 zones and a few thousand to almost 200,000 LEDs, while TCL’s CES 2020 V-Drean used 5,000 zones and 20,000 LEDs.
* Diminishing returns mean picture quality does not improve much above a few thousand zones, so midterm designs are expected to converge.
đź“‹ **Clip Abstract** MiniLED backlights extend full-array local dimming by multiplying LEDs and independent zones, improving contrast and black levels while increasing complexity and cost. Prototype zone and LED counts varied widely, but diminishing returns above a few thousand zones point toward midterm convergence in commercial designs.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Eric Virey
* Company: Yole Development
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#MiniLEDBacklights, #FullArrayLocalDimming, #ZoneLEDTradeoff, #DiminishingReturns, #DisplayBacklights, #ContrastEnhancement
20:21 - 21:59
How small must MicroLED dies get—from 125×225 to 10×10 or 5×5 microns—to make TV costs palatable?
How small must MicroLED dies get—from 125×225 to 10×10 or 5×5 microns—to make TV costs palatable?
The first-generation Samsung The Wall, introduced at CES 2018, used 125 by 225 micron die. The estimate is that the MicroLED die cost alone exceeded $35,000. The 110-inch quote-unquote TV reduces die size, so die cost comes down a little. By year-end, Samsung is hoped to introduce a real MicroLED TV with an LTPS TFT backplane and much smaller die from plain nitride.
Samsung will use 35 by 60 micron die from plain nitride, lowering die cost again significantly. Plain nitride partners such as AUO and Tianma are already working on next-generation die that are much smaller and therefore significantly cheaper. Achieving consumer-display palatability requires decreasing die size further to 10 by 10 micron, and probably closer to 5 by 5 micron.
An 8K TV needs four times more LEDs, so the die-count penalty offsets part of the savings. Yet the example shows how much cost could come down just by miniaturizing the MicroLED die. The path runs from 125 by 225 microns to 35 by 60, then toward 10 by 10 or 5 by 5, with backplane and die-supplier advances.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Die cost alone for 125 by 225 micron MicroLEDs in the CES 2018 The Wall exceeded $35,000.
* A 35 by 60 micron die from plain nitride is expected to lower cost again significantly.
* Consumer displays likely need 10 by 10 micron die, probably closer to 5 by 5, despite 8K needing four times more LEDs.
đź“‹ **Clip Abstract** MicroLED TV die cost falls as die size shrinks from 125 by 225 microns to 35 by 60 and toward 10 by 10 or 5 by 5 microns. Even though an 8K TV needs four times more LEDs, miniaturization is the lever for consumer-palatable cost.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Eric Virey
* Company: Yole Development
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#MicroLEDDieSize, #LTPSTFTBackplane, #PlainNitrideDie, #DieCostReduction, #MicroLEDDisplays, #DisplayEconomics
12:36 - 14:50
What makes Samsung's QD-OLED structure so hard to manufacture despite its color and contrast advantages?
What makes Samsung's QD-OLED structure so hard to manufacture despite its color and contrast advantages?
QD-OLED pairs a monochromatic blue OLED with a patterned quantum-dot color conversion layer, in an open mask process like LG's white OLED, giving high OLED material efficiency, wide color gamut and a top emission architecture. But the OLED stack alone must generate every photon for the TV, and it cannot be driven hard without lifetime falling off a cliff, so multiple layers must be stacked, raising cost and complexity.
Patterning the quantum dots is also quite challenging, and absorption is the bottleneck. Whether photolithography or inkjet printing is used, the loading of quantum dots into the ink or photoresist is limited, which caps absorption. Some blue photons therefore escape through the red and green converters and degrade the color gamut, forcing an additional color filter into the stack.
Top emission compounds the problem: the top cathode must be transparent, and transparent conductive materials are notoriously poor at current spreading. The likely remedy is extra bus lines, which brings an additional mask level and additional manufacturing complexity. Every one of these optical advantages arrives with a process penalty attached.
In this short video, you can learn:
* The blue OLED in QD-OLED must supply every photon the TV emits, so driving it harder trades directly against lifetime.
* Quantum-dot loading limits in photoresist or inkjet ink cap absorption, letting blue light leak through the red and green converters and pushing an extra color filter into the stack.
* A transparent top cathode forces bus lines for current spreading, adding a mask level and manufacturing complexity.
đź“‹ **Clip Abstract** QD-OLED combines a monochromatic blue OLED with a patterned quantum-dot color conversion layer in an open mask, top emission architecture that delivers wide color gamut and good material efficiency. Those gains are paid for in stacked emitting layers, limited quantum-dot absorption, an added color filter and extra bus lines for a weak transparent cathode.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Eric Virey
* Company: Yole Development
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#QDOLED, #QuantumDotPatterning, #TransparentTopCathode, #BusLineCurrentSpreading, #DisplayMaterials, #EmissiveDisplays
About this talk
→ Quantum Dots, OLED, MiniLED, MicroLED NanoLED: technology landscape for next generations TVs · Eric Virey · Displays & Lighting: Innovations & Market Trends 2021
Other talks by Eric Virey
- Can microLED succeed in high-volume consumer applications? · Mini- & Micro-LED Displays: Markets, Manufacturing Innovations, Applications, Promising Start-ups 2023
- Trends in miniLED technologies, market and supply chain. · Quantum Dots: Material Innovations and Commercial Applications 2022
More highlights from Eric Virey
- ▶ Why are display giants spending billions of dollars to transition MicroLED manufacturing to 8-inch and 6-inch wafer fabs? · Mini- & Micro-LED Displays 2023: Markets, Manufacturing Innovations, Applications, Promising Start-ups
- ▶ Can a mini-LED backlight truly match the pixel-level contrast of a self-emissive OLED display? · Mini- & Micro-LED Displays 2022: Markets, Manufacturing Innovations, Applications, Promising Start-ups
- ▶ Why did TCL drop its flagship mini-LED count by 90% in just one year? · Mini- & Micro-LED Displays 2022: Markets, Manufacturing Innovations, Applications, Promising Start-ups
- ▶ Is the rise of Gen 8.5 IT OLED fabs about to render mini-LED laptops and tablets obsolete? · Mini- & Micro-LED Displays 2022: Markets, Manufacturing Innovations, Applications, Promising Start-ups


