Max Marwede & David Sánchez | Fraunhofer IZM: Why is silver ink LCA data so variable — and does particle size actually change its environmental impact?
12:07 - 13:17
Other snippets from this talk
Summary of the clip:
Why is silver ink LCA data so variable — and does particle size actually change its environmental impact?
Prior literature and the project's own analysis both point to the same hotspot: conductive inks, and silver ink formulations in particular, are usually the drivers of environmental impact in printed electronics. Yet when the different data sources used to calculate those impacts are compared, the spread is wide, from literature values to existing commercial databases.
The data remains relatively uncertain, and there is no clear insight on whether particle size has a significant effect on the environmental impacts of manufacturing those inks. Equally open is the extent to which using secondary material for ink formulation is technically feasible, or economically feasible — a question the project flagged rather than resolved.
The project's conclusion is a call to the sector: look more closely not only at the environmental impacts of printed electronics as such, but also at the individual components that go into these modules, and bring more clarity there. End of life was named as the other aspect requiring attention.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Conductive inks, especially silver ink formulations, are usually the drivers of environmental impact in printed electronics, according to both prior literature and the project's analysis.
* Calculated impacts of these inks vary widely across literature and commercial databases, and the data remains relatively uncertain.
* There is still no clear insight into whether particle size significantly affects ink manufacturing impacts, nor into how far secondary material use is technically or economically feasible.
📋 **Clip Abstract** Silver conductive inks dominate the environmental impact profile of printed electronics, yet the LCA data used to quantify them varies widely between literature and commercial databases. Component-level impact clarity, secondary-material feasibility and end of life are flagged as the open questions the sector should address.
About the speakers:
* Speakers: Max Marwede, David Sánchez
* Company: Fraunhofer IZM
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
📅 Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
📍 Berlin, Germany
📋 Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#SilverInkLCA, #ConductiveInkImpacts, #ParticleSizeUncertainty, #SecondaryMaterialFeasibility, #PrintedElectronics, #LifeCycleAssessment
This is a highlight of the presentation:
Eco-Design for Printed Electronics: Utilizing LCA to Drive Circular Business Models
More Highlights from the same talk.
05:32 - 06:44
Does printing a luminaire lead strip with silver or copper conductive ink beat conventional PCB on environmental impact?
Does printing a luminaire lead strip with silver or copper conductive ink beat conventional PCB on environmental impact?
A luminaire pilot replaced the lead strip’s conventional PCB with a printed module, producing two versions: one using silver conductive ink and one using copper conductive ink. The comparison confirmed that printed modules have several environmental advantages over conventional PCBs, attributed in the clip to less material waste during production and a much less energy-intensive manufacturing process.
The result also confirms a main environmental hotspot for printed modules: the silver conductive ink, and more importantly the silver that comes with it. By comparison, substrates tend to play a minor role in the environmental impacts of printed modules. The comparison therefore places the conductive ink and its silver content ahead of the substrate as impact drivers.
The pilot presented silver and copper conductive-ink versions of a printed luminaire module, while attributing printed-module benefits to lower production material waste and less energy-intensive manufacturing. It identifies silver conductive ink—and more importantly the silver it contains—as the main environmental hotspot, with substrates playing a comparatively minor role in printed modules’ impacts.
In this short video, you can learn:
* A luminaire pilot replaced a conventional PCB lead strip with printed modules using silver and copper conductive inks.
* Printed modules showed environmental advantages from less production material waste and much less energy-intensive manufacturing.
* Silver conductive ink, especially its silver content, was the main hotspot, while substrates played a minor role.
📋 **Clip Abstract** A luminaire pilot substituted a conventional PCB lead strip with printed modules in silver- and copper-ink versions. The comparison confirmed printed modules’ environmental advantages from lower material waste and less energy-intensive manufacturing, while identifying silver conductive ink and its silver content as the main hotspot and substrates as minor.
About the speakers:
* Speakers: Max Marwede, David Sánchez
* Company: Fraunhofer IZM
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
📅 Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
📍 Berlin, Germany
📋 Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#SilverConductiveInk, #CopperConductiveInk, #PrintedLuminaireModule, #MaterialWasteReduction, #PrintedElectronics, #LifeCycleAssessment
15:40 - 17:24
Why is eco-design ex post costly, and how do you set sustainability specs before product decisions lock in?
Why is eco-design ex post costly, and how do you set sustainability specs before product decisions lock in?
At the start of an R&D project the data gaps are widest: many decisions are unmade, so there is not enough information to assess sustainability. The trade-off is structural — every decision taken adds data but removes freedom to change the product, so influence over sustainability falls as certainty rises. Eco-design done ex post, when the product is already ready, is therefore costly.
The answer is an iterative approach, as in technology development: research requirements, including policy and customer sustainability requirements; run a benchmark analysis, an LCA of the former product; identify environmental hotspots from it; prioritise eco-design strategies such as modularity; and set sustainability goals, for example a 20% or 10% CO2 reduction.
Those goals must then be broken down into specifications — energy used during the use phase, or more sustainable materials, depending on the hotspot analysis — before entering research. That research step asks which technologies exist, what can be used, and how they compare to alternatives on performance, so material and process choices are screened against the targets rather than after the fact.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Decision influence falls as data accumulates, so eco-design has to be loaded to the front of the project.
* ,An LCA benchmark of the previous product turns early data gaps into named environmental hotspots and a prioritised set of eco-design strategies including modularity.
* Top-level targets such as a 20% or 10% CO2 reduction only become actionable once broken down into use-phase energy or material specifications.
📋 **Clip Abstract** Eco-design fails when it arrives after the product is finished: data is plentiful then, but the freedom to change the design is gone. The clip sets out an iterative route from requirements and a benchmark LCA of the former product, through hotspots, modularity strategies and quantified goals, down to use-phase and material specifications for technology screening.
About the speakers:
* Speakers: Max Marwede, David Sánchez
* Company: Fraunhofer IZM
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
📅 Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
📍 Berlin, Germany
📋 Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#EcoDesignHotspots, #LCABenchmark, #ModularityStrategy, #UsePhaseEnergySpecs, #SustainableElectronics, #CircularElectronics
10:06 - 10:59
Can a more complex reusable electrode design cut per-use impact below a fully disposable patch?
Can a more complex reusable electrode design cut per-use impact below a fully disposable patch?
A pilot application measuring brain activity moved away from a sealed disposable patch: the design was made fully modular so the metal electrodes themselves can be removed from the little patches and reused again, while the disposable part is simplified as much as possible.
Per piece, the modular electrode design looks worse. Its environmental impact is significantly higher than that of the simple disposable patch, because the reusable version carries many more layers and a much more complex design. That complexity is the price paid for repeated use of the metal.
The per-use impact, shown in the right corner of the graphic, tells the opposite story. Spread across uses, the modular design comes down to the same impact as the simpler, fully disposable versions, or even slightly lower — with much less e-waste and metal waste at the end of the day.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Removing the metal electrodes from the patch for reuse raises per-piece impact significantly through many more layers and a more complex design.
* On a per-use basis the modular design falls to the same impact as simpler fully disposable versions, or slightly lower.
* The payoff is much less e-waste and metal waste at the end of the day.
📋 **Clip Abstract** A brain-activity electrode pilot was redesigned as a fully modular patch in which the metal electrodes are removed and reused, with the disposable part simplified as much as possible. Per piece the design carries a significantly higher impact from extra layers and complexity, but per use it matches or slightly undercuts fully disposable versions while cutting e-waste and metal waste.
About the speakers:
* Speakers: Max Marwede, David Sánchez
* Company: Fraunhofer IZM
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
📅 Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
📍 Berlin, Germany
📋 Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#ReusableMetalElectrodes, #PerUseImpact, #ModularPatchDesign, #EEGElectrodePilot, #SustainableElectronics, #CircularElectronics
Links to this speaker's talk page and other highlights appear here.


