Peter Palomaki | Palomaki Consulting: If the cadmium RoHS exemption expires, does EL QLED’s tiny 50 mg loading keep it compliant?
08:22 - 10:04
Other snippets from this talk
Summary of the clip:
If the cadmium RoHS exemption expires, does EL QLED’s tiny 50 mg loading keep it compliant?
EU RoHS currently limits cadmium to 100 ppm and lead to 1,000 ppm. A cadmium exemption is in place but may expire after a European Commission vote. If limits roll back to 100 ppm, most cadmium-containing films become obsolete except hybrid indium phosphide red with cad cell green maintaining 100 ppm cadmium or less. Perovskite color filters are a non-starter because lead content is too high, and cadmium-free QDs reign superior.
For electroluminescent quantum dot LEDs, the transcript plots estimated material use by form factor. An edge optic is an older approach no longer around. Films might use about a gram of quantum dots; a color-filter TV might use 5 grams; electroluminescent might use 50 milligrams. That is an extremely low quantum-dot loading, and therefore low cadmium loading. Whether it is low enough for RoHS compliance is still up in the air for cadmium-based systems.
The chart is an estimate, and the speaker does not declare EL QLED compliant. The comparison puts EL QLED at 50 mg versus about 1 g in films and 5 g in a color-filter TV. That gap is why the cadmium-loading question matters: the same 100 ppm threshold would apply, but the absolute amount is far smaller. The answer for cadmium-based EL systems remains unresolved.
In this short video, you can learn:
* EU RoHS sets cadmium at 100 ppm and lead at 1,000 ppm, with a cadmium exemption that may expire after a European Commission vote.
* If it ends, most cadmium-containing films become obsolete except hybrid indium phosphide red with cad cell green at 100 ppm or less, while perovskite color filters fail on lead and cadmium-free QDs reign superior.
* Estimated quantum-dot use is about 1 g in films, 5 g in a color-filter TV and 50 mg in EL QLED, so cadmium-based EL compliance remains up in the air.
📋 **Clip Abstract** EU RoHS limits cadmium to 100 ppm and lead to 1,000 ppm, and the cadmium exemption may expire after a Commission vote. Comparing estimated quantum-dot loadings—1 g in films, 5 g in color-filter TVs and 50 mg in EL—the speaker says cadmium-based EL compliance remains up in the air.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Peter Palomaki
* Company: Palomaki Consulting
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#CadmiumRoHSExemption, #IndiumPhosphideRed, #CadmiumFreeQDs, #PerovskiteColorFilters, #QLEDDisplays, #DisplayMaterials
This is a highlight of the presentation:
Electroluminescent QLED: Technology Progress & Roadmap
More Highlights from the same talk.
05:00 - 07:28
Why can’t a high-performance photoluminescent quantum dot simply be dropped into an electroluminescent QLED?
Why can’t a high-performance photoluminescent quantum dot simply be dropped into an electroluminescent QLED?
Photoluminescent quantum dots have had roughly two decades of optimization, while electroluminescent versions have only seen concentrated effort in the last few years. A photoluminescent dot can be transferred into electroluminescence, but it will work and not be very good. The differences include material composition, shell thickness, matrix and surface ligands, so direct substitution leaves important material differences.
For photoluminescent display materials, the dominant compositions are indium phosphide-based and cadmium selenide-based, with perovskites described as up-and-coming but not yet widely commercial at scale. Electroluminescence uses some of the same materials: indium phosphide works and cadmium selenide works really well. For blue emission, zinc tellurium selenium has emerged in the last few years, specifically targeted at blue quantum-dot emission and as a substitute for cadmium-based material.
Shell design changes as well: photoluminescent dots often use very thick shells for protection and robustness, whereas electroluminescent dots need electrons to pass through the shell, so overly thick shells can be undesirable and thinner shells are generally used. The matrix also differs: photoluminescent dots are dispersed in a polymer, while electroluminescent dots are formulated into an ink, deposited on a substrate and evaporated, leaving dots sandwiched by other materials. Surface ligands are generally long hydrophobic.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Two decades of photoluminescent optimization do not directly satisfy electroluminescent requirements; transferred dots work but are not very good.
* Electroluminescent blue dots use zinc tellurium selenium to target blue emission and substitute for cadmium-based material.
* Electroluminescence favors thinner shells, an ink that is evaporated to leave no polymer matrix, and generally long hydrophobic surface ligands.
📋 **Clip Abstract** The clip explains why photoluminescent quantum dots cannot simply be moved into electroluminescent QLEDs: two decades of optimization have targeted photoluminescence, while electroluminescence has only recently received focused effort. It compares indium phosphide, cadmium selenide and zinc tellurium selenium compositions, then details shell thickness, ink-deposited matrix removal and surface-ligand differences.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Peter Palomaki
* Company: Palomaki Consulting
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#ElectroluminescentQLED, #ZincTelluriumSelenium, #QuantumDotShellThickness, #InkEvaporatedQuantumDots, #DisplayMaterials, #QuantumDotDisplays
16:49 - 18:14
How far behind are cadmium-free and blue EL QLEDs when normalized to T95 at 1,000 nits?
How far behind are cadmium-free and blue EL QLEDs when normalized to T95 at 1,000 nits?
The comparison is plotted as T95 at 1,000 nits, with results adjusted or estimated to that metric where reports used other formats. A dotted line marks what may be commercially viable, perhaps 10,000 hours. Only green and red cadmium-based systems reach that line; the other material/color combinations sit far behind.
The plot uses a log scale, and the difference between log and linear scales matters. On a linear scale, cadmium-free materials barely show up because they are so far behind. Blue materials are also extremely low compared with red and green, making the required blue improvement visually stark.
The chart highlights how much improvement is required for blue and for non-cadmium materials to catch up with cadmium-based materials. They are described as a long ways off, while cadmium-based materials have made excellent progress. The full apples-to-apples view covers cadmium and non-cadmium and red, green and blue.
In this short video, you can learn:
* The T95 comparison at 1,000 nits adjusted or estimated reported results so cadmium and non-cadmium, red, green and blue could be compared.
* Only green and red cadmium-based systems reach the dotted line for commercial viability, which is perhaps 10,000 hours.
* On a linear scale, cadmium-free materials barely show up, and blue is extremely low compared with red and green.
📋 **Clip Abstract** An apples-to-apples T95-at-1,000-nits plot compares cadmium and non-cadmium EL QLED materials across red, green and blue. Only green and red cadmium-based systems reach the dotted roughly 10,000-hour commercial-viability line, while cadmium-free and blue materials are far behind on the log plot and barely visible on a linear scale.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Peter Palomaki
* Company: Palomaki Consulting
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#CadmiumBasedQLED, #CadmiumFreeMaterials, #BlueELQLED, #T95At1000Nits, #QLEDDisplays, #DisplayMetrology
13:18 - 15:09
What T50 lifetimes did Samsung report for cadmium-free blue and red electroluminescent QLEDs?
What T50 lifetimes did Samsung report for cadmium-free blue and red electroluminescent QLEDs?
Samsung, described as a QLED leader, reported best-in-class cadmium-free blue and red electroluminescent quantum-dot performance. Its blue devices, published in a 2020 Nature paper, used zinc-telluride-based quantum dots with no cadmium or lead and a special surface-chemistry treatment. The reported T50 lifetime was over 15,000 hours at 100 nits, which the talk calls excellent versus prior published blue results and notes blue is the poorest-performing color by lifetime.
For red, Samsung used indium phosphide-based quantum dots and specific shell thickness and shell chemistry, showing how the shells affected results. The reported lifetime was over 1 million hours T50 at 100 nits. The speaker stresses that this is T50 at 100 nits, and later notes that other data is reported in slightly different ways, an inconsistency issue for the industry.
The comparison matters because blue devices are the weakest color for lifetime, so Samsung’s over-15,000-hour blue T50 at 100 nits is framed against earlier published results. Red’s over-1-million-hour T50 at 100 nits is striking, but the talk cautions that lifetime reporting varies across the industry and says it will try to normalize the data for comparison.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Samsung’s cadmium-free blue EL QDs used zinc-telluride quantum dots with special surface chemistry and reached over 15,000 hours T50 at 100 nits.
* Samsung’s cadmium-free red EL QDs used indium phosphide quantum dots with tailored shell thickness and chemistry and reached over 1 million hours T50 at 100 nits.
* The talk flags inconsistent lifetime-reporting practices across the industry and attempts to normalize the data.
📋 **Clip Abstract** Samsung reported cadmium-free electroluminescent QLED lifetimes of over 15,000 hours T50 at 100 nits for blue devices and over 1 million hours T50 at 100 nits for red devices. The blue results used zinc-telluride quantum dots with special surface chemistry, while the red results used indium phosphide quantum dots with tailored shells, and the talk notes inconsistent reporting across the industry.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Peter Palomaki
* Company: Palomaki Consulting
* Event: Displays & Lighting 2021: Innovations & Market Trends
Join TechBlick to learn about the cutting edge in the display industry
https://www.techblick.com/
#CadmiumFreeQLED, #ZincTellurideQD, #IndiumPhosphideQD, #T50Lifetime, #ElectroluminescentQLED, #QuantumDotDisplays
About this talk
→ Electroluminescent QLED: Technology Progress & Roadmap · Peter Palomaki · Displays & Lighting: Innovations & Market Trends 2021
Other talks by Peter Palomaki
- A peek inside QD-enabled displays · Quantum Dots: Material Innovations and Commercial Applications 2022


