Johanna Zikulnig | Silicon Austria Labs: Why is recovering high-value printed silver and copper from municipal incineration and recycling streams practically impossible today?
00:09:00 - 00:11:09
Other snippets from this talk
Summary of the clip:
Why is recovering high-value printed silver and copper from municipal incineration and recycling streams practically impossible today?
While incineration with energy recovery is often proposed for printed electronic waste, non-carbon components like metallic electrodes and silicon chips do not burn. Instead, these micro- and nanoscale metallic particles melt and accumulate within the bottom ash and fly ash of incineration facilities. Although some macro-scale metal recovery is common in waste management, separating and reclaiming ultra-fine printed metal particles from ash remains economically and technically unfeasible.
This creates a significant material circularity gap because these printed metals, which could theoretically be recycled indefinitely with up to an 80% reduction in CO2 emissions, end up in construction aggregates or landfills. The value of these strategic metals is permanently lost, even if the high temperatures of incineration melt them into larger, less bioavailable compounds.
The root of the problem is that there is currently no efficient industrial-scale recycling method in place to separate printed metallic traces from plastic or paper substrates before disposal. Developing advanced separation technologies, such as sacrificial release layers, is crucial to transitioning printed electronics from a linear "use-and-lose" model to a true circular economy.
In this short video, you can learn:
* The fate of metallic electrodes during waste incineration and their accumulation in bottom and fly ash.
* Why recovering ultra-fine printed metal particles from municipal ash remains economically unfeasible.
* The gap between theoretical infinite metal recyclability and the lack of practical separation methods for printed devices.
π **Clip Abstract** This segment exposes the severe limitations of current waste management systems in reclaiming precious metals from incinerated or recycled printed sensors. Scientist Johanna Zikulnig explains why fine metallic traces end up permanently lost in bottom ash, underscoring the urgent need for design-for-recycling innovations.
#SacrificialReleaseLayers, #BottomAshRecovery, #PrintedMetalRecycling, #FineParticleSeparation, #PrintedElectronics, #CircularElectronics
This is a highlight of the presentation:
More Highlights from the same talk.
03:25 - 05:14
Why is silver still the gold standard when carbon inks have far lower environmental impact?
Why is silver still the gold standard when carbon inks have far lower environmental impact?
In the life cycle assessment, primary silver is the most impactful electrode material, followed by secondary silver, while copper and carbon sit comparatively low on environmental impact. Two caveats frame the comparison: only primary materials are counted, and the figures come from the itemat database. Even so, the ranking is unambiguous β the material with the heaviest footprint remains the performance benchmark for printed electronics.
Silver nanoparticle ink is still treated as the gold standard for performance, while carbon inks offer outstanding environmental benefits. The barrier is functional: typical carbon sheet resistances run around 1,000 times higher than silver nanoparticle inks. That rules out antenna structures, which need a high quality factor for efficient wireless reading and communication. The trade-off is measurable, not philosophical.
Suitable niches do exist. Printed electrochemical sensors benefit from carbon's larger surface area, and printed heaters and sensors are viable. A resistive temperature sensor built on bio-based carbon was demonstrated alongside a heater, verified with a thermal image. Matching material to function, rather than substituting material for material, is where the sustainability case holds.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Primary silver carries the highest environmental impact in the LCA, ahead of secondary silver, with copper and carbon far lower.
* Carbon ink sheet resistance is roughly 1,000 times higher than silver nanoparticle ink, so high-quality-factor antennas stay out of reach.
* Printed electrochemical sensors, printed heaters and a bio-based carbon resistive temperature sensor are demonstrated viable applications.
π **Clip Abstract** A life cycle assessment ranks primary silver as the most impactful electrode material, yet silver nanoparticle ink remains the performance benchmark against far lower-impact carbon. Because carbon sheet resistance is around 1,000 times higher, the workable route is application matching: electrochemical sensors, heaters and bio-based carbon temperature sensors rather than antennas.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Johanna Zikulnig
* Company: Silicon Austria Labs GmbH
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
π
Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
π Berlin, Germany
π Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#SilverNanoparticleInk, #CarbonSheetResistance, #PrintedElectrochemicalSensors, #BioBasedCarbonHeater, #PrintedElectronics, #LifeCycleAssessment
08:37 - 10:28
Does encapsulation extend the lifetime of printed copper antennas in 85/85 testing?
Does encapsulation extend the lifetime of printed copper antennas in 85/85 testing?
Accelerated life testing ran in a climatic chamber at 85% relative humidity and 85Β°C, comparing antenna configurations in terms of resistance. The comparison covered different encapsulation strategies and silver versus copper metallisation on the printed device antenna. Resistance was the tracked degradation metric throughout the constant-humidity exposure.
Silver performed better and actually improved over time in the climatic chamber, showing post-curing effects. Copper slowly degraded in conductivity. But weighed against the expected device lifetime and the target quality factor, the copper antenna's quality factor never reaches the critical value that would prevent wireless readout of the device.
Comparing encapsulation strategies for the printed copper circuit gave the surprise: essentially no difference between the different encapsulations, and even bare copper, apart from one outlier. All configurations performed the same under the same 85/85 conditions across the tracked resistance measurements. The conclusion was that the encapsulation can simply be discarded here, because it makes no big difference.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Silver antennas improved in conductivity during 85/85 climatic chamber testing through post-curing effects, while copper degraded slowly.
* Within the expected device lifetime, the copper antenna's quality factor never falls to the critical value that would block wireless readout.
* Encapsulation strategy made no measurable difference for the printed copper circuit, even bare copper, except one outlier, so encapsulation was discarded.
π **Clip Abstract** Accelerated life testing at 85% relative humidity and 85Β°C compared silver and copper printed antennas and several encapsulation strategies by tracking resistance. Silver improved through post-curing while copper degraded slowly but stayed above the critical quality factor for wireless readout, and encapsulation showed no benefit even against bare copper, apart from a single outlier.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Johanna Zikulnig
* Company: Silicon Austria Labs GmbH
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
π
Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
π Berlin, Germany
π Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#PrintedCopperAntenna, #EncapsulationStrategy, #SilverVsCopper, #AcceleratedLifeTesting, #PrintedElectronics, #SustainableElectronics
06:50 - 08:24
Why did recycled PET beat cellulose diacetate and a novel algae substrate in LCA?
Why did recycled PET beat cellulose diacetate and a novel algae substrate in LCA?
Substrates represent the largest portion of a printed electronics system by both weight and volume. While replacing standard polymers with bio-based alternatives appears environmentally advantageous, comparative evaluations reveal surprising trade-offs. Assessing recycled polyethylene terephthalate, cellulose diacetate, and a custom algae-based substrate demonstrates that recycled PET exhibits lower overall environmental impact across most evaluated categories than its bio-based counterparts.
The novel algae-based substrate demonstrated slightly better environmental metrics across key evaluation categories than reference cellulose diacetate, yet neither bio-based option matched recycled PET. Recycled PET performs remarkably well regarding initial environmental footprint metrics, but it completely lacks biodegradability. Consequently, discarded PET substrates persist within ecosystems for many years, raising fundamental design questions about material end-of-life.
Selecting an optimal printed electronics substrate requires evaluating functional application demands against end-of-life requirements rather than assuming bio-based materials are inherently greener. While recycled PET minimizes initial environmental impact, disposable applications may mandate biodegradable alternatives like cellulose diacetate or algae-derived materials. Engineers must determine whether environmental footprint reduction or post-consumer biodegradability governs their specific system requirements.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Recycled PET achieved lower overall environmental impact across evaluation categories than bio-based cellulose diacetate and algae substrates.
* The novel algae-based material performed slightly better in environmental impact categories than reference cellulose diacetate.
* Substrate selection must balance overall environmental footprint against mandatory biodegradability requirements for disposable printed electronics.
π **Clip Abstract** Comparative assessments of printed electronics substrates show that recycled PET outperforms cellulose diacetate and novel algae-based materials across key environmental impact categories. However, non-biodegradable PET persists indefinitely in ecosystems, forcing engineers to weigh overall environmental footprint against end-of-life biodegradability needs.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Johanna Zikulnig
* Company: Silicon Austria Labs GmbH
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
π
Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
π Berlin, Germany
π Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#RecycledPET, #CelluloseDiacetate, #AlgaeSubstrate, #EnvironmentalImpact, #PrintedElectronics, #SustainableElectronics
Other talks by Johanna Zikulnig
- Sustainable Materials in Printed Electronics: Promise, Reality, and Open Challenges Β· Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 Berlin
- From Innovation to Obsolescence: The End-of-Life Challenges of Printed Sensors Β· Perovskites Innovation Day 2025
More highlights from Johanna Zikulnig
- βΆ Why is silver still the gold standard when carbon inks have far lower environmental impact? Β· Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- βΆ Why did recycled PET beat cellulose diacetate and a novel algae substrate in LCA? Β· Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- βΆ Does encapsulation extend the lifetime of printed copper antennas in 85/85 testing? Β· Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- βΆ Does chip packaging cost sustainability or buy lifetime? Climatic-chamber data on hybrid printed devices suggests the lifetime multiplier wins. Β· Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- βΆ Are "green" single-use printed sensors actually creating an unmanaged, toxic waste stream outside of traditional e-waste recycling? Β· Additive, Sustainable or 3D Electronics Innovations Day 2025
- βΆ Why are standard Life Cycle Assessments dangerously blind to the long-term nanoparticle toxicity of landfilled printed electronics? Β· Additive, Sustainable or 3D Electronics Innovations Day 2025


