Lina Kadura | CEA: Silver ink drives 63% of a printed PCB's impact — does copper fix it?
35:05 - 37:33
Other snippets from this talk
Summary of the clip:
Silver ink drives 63% of a printed PCB's impact — does copper fix it?
Printing the PCB cut global warming potential by about 50%, but ozone depletion potential and mineral extraction worsened. Those penalties trace mainly to silver usage and PET substrate. A cradle-to-cradle sensitivity analysis assumed end-of-life recycling of both silver and PET, with materials reinjected into new devices. This is not far from reality: Coron project partners developed a process recovering PET monomer and silver ink, while another partner purifies silver for later reformulation.
Recycled PET improved ozone depletion potential, and recycled silver reduced another indicator substantially. Overall, printed electronics delivered a 50% to 60% reduction in global warming potential. Within the printed electronics itself, silver accounts for 63% of the impact. A sensitivity analysis substituting copper for silver drops that share to 27%. Next year, the project will build this PCB using copper inks and bio-based substrates. The results indicate that truly sustainable printed PCBs require low-impact materials, because silver remains the dominant burden.
That 63% silver share is the central problem for additive PCB manufacturing. Copper inks promise to cut the material impact to 27%, but they must match silver's conductivity and reliability. The planned copper-ink PCB, combined with bio-based substrates, will test whether additive manufacturing can move from a 50% GWP gain to a genuinely low-impact process. Cradle-to-cradle recycling of PET and silver already shows the direction, yet the conclusion is clear: to go really sustainable, use low-impact materials, not silver.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Printing the PCB cuts GWP by roughly 50%, but silver and PET raise ozone depletion potential and mineral extraction.
* Cradle-to-cradle recycling recovers PET monomer and silver ink, and recycled silver plus recycled PET reduce those indicators.
* Silver causes 63% of the printed PCB impact; substituting copper drops it to 27%, with copper inks and bio-based substrates planned next year.
📋 **Clip Abstract** Additive PCB manufacturing cuts global warming potential by about 50%, yet silver ink and PET worsen ozone depletion and mineral extraction. Cradle-to-cradle recycling and copper-ink substitution—dropping silver's impact from 63% to 27%—point to low-impact materials as the real sustainability lever.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Lina Kadura
* Company: CEA
* Event: The Future of Electronics RESHAPED 2025
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
🗓️ Save the date for the next Future of Electronic RESHAPED conference and exhibition
USA | Mountain View | 9-10 June 2027 : https://www.techblick.com/electronicsreshapedusa
Europe | Berlin | 20-21 October 2027: https://www.techblick.com/electronicsreshaped
#PrintedPCB, #SilverInk, #CopperInk, #CradleToCradle, #PrintedElectronics, #SustainableElectronics
This is a highlight of the presentation:
Advancing PCB Technology Through Additive Manufacturing: Process, Sustainability, and Reliability
More Highlights from the same talk.
04:37 - 06:04
How much GWP reduction does additive PCB manufacturing deliver versus conventional FR4 boards?
How much GWP reduction does additive PCB manufacturing deliver versus conventional FR4 boards?
There is no stacking involved: everything is printed on both sides of the substrate. The life-cycle results come from a partner in Ecotron, using the methodology shown on screen and the Ecoinvent database. Partner ITENE normalised all results against the conventional PCB, the blue reference, then modelled two scenarios on top of that baseline.
Generation one, the brown bars, changes only the process while end-of-life stays identical, meaning both boards are incinerated, and it already gains about 50% in GWP. Generation two pushes the project's limits: one partner recycles the PCB, separating the PET from the silver, and another partner purifies that silver, so everything is assumed recycled.
The extra gain in generation two comes from two factors, PET production and silver, both now recycled, taking total GWP reduction from 50% to 60%. The Ecotron assessment also assumed an industrial scale, because every underlying measurement is lab-scale data rather than production data.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Normalised against the conventional PCB with an incineration end-of-life, the first-generation process alone already delivers roughly 50% GWP reduction.
* Separating PET from silver and purifying the silver lifts the total GWP gain to between 50% and 60%.
* All measurements are lab-scale, so the Ecotron assessment assumed industrial scale to make the comparison.
📋 **Clip Abstract** A life-cycle assessment normalised against the conventional PCB shows that switching to a printed, double-sided, stack-free process cuts GWP by about 50% with end-of-life unchanged. Adding PET separation and silver purification pushes the reduction to 50-60%, though the figures rest on lab-scale data scaled to industrial production.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Lina Kadura
* Company: CEA- Liten
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
📅 Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
📍 Berlin, Germany
📋 Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#AdditivePCB, #EcoinventLCA, #SilverPurification, #GWPReduction, #PrintedElectronics, #SustainableElectronics
10:26 - 12:09
What makes screen-printed PCB fabrication a European re-industrialization opportunity?
What makes screen-printed PCB fabrication a European re-industrialization opportunity?
Subtractive versus additive is the obvious fabrication split, but the real point here is geography: both fabrication and materials are massively dominated by Asia. Even European PCB manufacturers hit a bottleneck on FR4 and cover. That dependency is reframed as an opportunity, because the ink and substrate providers are still quite European, which is the materials base for re-industrializing PCB production on the continent.
Screen printing is the chosen route at CEA, picked for high throughput, low cost and large-surface manufacturing, and upscalable through sheet-to-sheet or roll-to-roll. Inks span silver, copper-based and carbon systems. The resolution achieved today is documented, with headroom to go lower. The caveat: resolution must be managed by layer stacking and reproducibility once you target increasingly complex PCBs.
Beyond cost, screen printing is described as versatile: it offers a design flexibility that conventional PCB does not, expressed at the level of individual layers. Combine that with a still-European ink and substrate base, and screen-printed PCB fabrication becomes a re-industrialization argument, not simply a substitution of one deposition method for another.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Both PCB fabrication and its materials are massively dominated by Asia, leaving even European manufacturers with an FR4 and cover bottleneck.
* Screen printing was selected for high throughput, low cost, large surface area and sheet-to-sheet or roll-to-roll upscalability.
* Resolution must be handled through layer stacking and reproducibility as PCB complexity rises.
📋 **Clip Abstract** Additive screen printing replaces the subtractive flow, but the strategic point is supply: FR4 and cover stock come from Asia while inks and substrates remain largely European. CEA's screen-printing route, using silver, copper or carbon and upscalable sheet-to-sheet or roll-to-roll, trades resolution headroom for throughput and layer-level design freedom.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Lina Kadura
* Company: CEA- Liten
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
📅 Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
📍 Berlin, Germany
📋 Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#ScreenPrinting, #AdditivePCBFabrication, #FR4SupplyChain, #LayerStacking, #PrintedElectronics, #SustainableElectronics
08:23 - 10:08
Why can't conventional PCB CAD tools automatically design-check a printed multilayer board?
Why can't conventional PCB CAD tools automatically design-check a printed multilayer board?
The schematic does not depend on the fabrication step, so it stays identical between conventional and printed technologies. The layout does not: it depends entirely on the fabrication process, the design rules you set, your layer stack, the thicknesses, and the materials you use. That is where the two flows diverge, before any board is built.
In the conventional flow you draw copper traces most of the time and do not draw the insulator, because the substrate is FR4. In printed electronics you must also lay out the dielectric insulator, since you print it as well. Vias differ too: conventionally they are drilled through all the substrates that are then stacked.
In printed electronics only the vias in the core or substrates need drilling; all the others between layers are printed, simply an area where no dielectric is deposited, so they are free — included directly in the dielectric layer design. The gap: no CAD tool today offers automatic design rule checking for complex printed PCBs.
In this short video, you can learn:
* Schematic capture is identical across the two technologies; only the layout depends on fabrication, design rules, layer stack, thicknesses and materials.
* Conventional FR4 design draws copper only, whereas printed electronics must also lay out the dielectric insulator that has to be printed.
* Only core and substrate vias are drilled in printed boards; interlayer vias are printed dielectric-free areas, and no CAD tool yet automatically checks such complex designs.
📋 **Clip Abstract** Layout, not schematic, is where printed and conventional PCB design split: printed boards need the dielectric drawn and interlayer vias printed rather than drilled. Conventional CAD tools are established and efficient, but none yet offers automatic design rule checking for complex printed PCBs — a real limit on fabricating them.
About the speaker:
* Speaker: Lina Kadura
* Company: CEA- Liten
* Event: Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
* Location: Estrel, Berlin
Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED | Berlin
📅 Save the date: 20 and 21 October 2027
📍 Berlin, Germany
📋 Info: https://www.techblick.com/sustainableelectronicsreshaped
#DesignRuleCheck, #PrintedDielectric, #ViaDrilling, #LayerStackDesign, #PrintedElectronics, #SustainableElectronics
Other talks by Lina Kadura
- From Subtractive to Additive: Transforming PCB Production for Sustainable Electronics · Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 Berlin
- Printed processes for PCBs manufacturing: towards sustainable electronics · Printed Electronics Innovation Day | Winter 2024
More highlights from Lina Kadura
- ▶ How much GWP reduction does additive PCB manufacturing deliver versus conventional FR4 boards? · Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- ▶ Why can't conventional PCB CAD tools automatically design-check a printed multilayer board? · Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- ▶ What makes screen-printed PCB fabrication a European re-industrialization opportunity? · Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- ▶ Can printed PCBs be assembled with standard SAC-305 reflow and IPC processes? · Sustainable Electronics RESHAPED 2026 | Berlin
- ▶ Can we really slash PCB carbon footprint by 50% simply by switching from subtractive etching to additive screen printing? · Printed Electronics Innovation Day 2024
- ▶ How do you design and print an 8-layer additive stackup with 200-micron vias on a single flexible PET sheet? · Printed Electronics Innovation Day 2024
- ▶ What are the physical resolution and conductivity trade-offs when shifting from bulk copper to screen-printed silver inks? · Printed Electronics Innovation Day 2024


